Research shows that boys bully and girls defend victims from bullying. In a society that thinks of boys as heroes, how did we let girls take over the “good guy” role? The answer may help us solve some problems.
Once we get over the idea of the stereotypical action hero stepping in and saving the day, we start to consider that, in our culture, girls are often thought of as nurturing while boys are often thought of as aggressive. In this context, we can understand how girls are the ones who try to help victims in a pinch, while boys are the ones doing the pinching. This difference in behavior creates some disadvantages for boys…and men.
The tendency to help victims is associated with all kinds of enviable characteristics, like high “genuine” self-esteem, exceptional moral reasoning, academic confidence, and other positive attributes. These qualities are, in turn, associated with healthy and successful lives. But a tendency to bully is associated with criminal activity, drug problems, relationship failure, and other negative life outcomes.
So, should boys just resign themselves to being bullies, and victims, while girls mop up all the glory and success? I mean boys are boys, right? They are just naturally aggressive, right? Well, yes and NO. Research suggests that these differences in behavior between boys and girls come more from societal expectations than any innate traits. We expect boys to bully and we expect girls to help out, so they do.
These societal expectations are so powerful that, even when girls do bully, they do it in a more complex, social way. They engage in social sabotage because in our society girls are thought of as social and sophisticated, while boys are thought of as direct and physical.
However, in our society masculinity is favored over femininity. And recent research is discovering some disturbing changes in girls’ behavior. It looks as if girls are now adopting some of the worst male-stereotyped behavior. They are increasing their criminal involvement and they are committing more acts of physical aggression. Bad news, but it suggests a solution.
Parents, friends, and teachers are the conduits of social expectations. Boys and girls know how to behave because those who are close to them expect them to behave in certain ways. If we expect our boys to be nurturing and helpful and unaggressive, chances are that they will meet those expectations.
Having a mindset that boys should be loving and helpful is not really that new, even in our society. The iconic American male is often the one who stands against the crowd, lends a hand, champions the underdog, and applies tenderness where it’s needed. We just seem to forget those aspects of manliness too often. But we can’t continue to ignore that part of being a man anymore, not if we want our boys to be as successful and healthy as our girls.
Some ways to encourage the best in our boys and our girls:
§ Watch movies where men stick up for others without using violence.
§ Watch movies where women take on tough challenges and win.
§ Talk to your boys about what it means to be a man. Listen to what they say, and remind them that men are sweet and gentle, loving and kind.
§ Tell your girls that they should be proud of being girls, that they are strong women in the making. Ask them what they think it means to be women.
§ Cultivate in yourself a new vision of maleness and femaleness. Realize that many male and female stereotypes are not based in reality. Your expectations affect your children’s behavior.
§ Look at your own relationships. Do you stick to feminine and masculine stereotypes to your own detriment? Is there domestic violence or unfairness in your interactions? Changing these dynamics will set a tremendous example for the kids you care for.
§ Discuss popular media with children. Talk to them about the stereotypes you see for men and women in music, movies, and television.
§ Make sure that you know the crowd your children hang out with. Peer expectations can make much of the difference.